THE DAILY

Tuesday, April 21, 2026

The five minutes that makes you the most informed person in freight today

The Daily

C.H. Robinson points to FMCSA as CBS puts broker safety on stage

Six weeks after arguing broker liability before the Supreme Court, C.H. Robinson (NASDAQ: CHRW) woke up Sunday to a CBS News report that dragged the brokerage industry into a fight it has spent decades trying to keep on the federal docket.

The CBS segment, an extension of last weekend’s “60 Minutes” piece on “chameleon carriers,” singled out Robinson as a 3PL that hired trucking companies with spotty safety records. The network said its reporting identified thousands of carriers hired by Robinson that had a history of safety issues, including dozens that showed the hallmarks of a chameleon operation — same trucks, same owner, new name on the door.

Robinson fired back within hours of the broadcast, and the defense sounded familiar to anyone who watched March’s oral arguments in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. “We work exclusively with carriers that have been vetted and licensed by FMCSA,” the company said in its statement. Robinson argued that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, not brokers, has the data and authority to judge carrier fitness, and said its booking system automatically blocks any carrier that loses its operating authority, insurance or DOT number. The company cited a ratio of one serious accident claim for every 500 million miles on its customers’ loads.

The plaintiff side in the court of public opinion has a simpler pitch. “Trust me, I’m upset with the driver, I’m upset with the carrier, but if we don’t go after the broker, this is going to continue happening,” Marcus Coleman, whose daughter Dalilah was struck by a truck driver in 2024, told CBS. His family is suing Robinson in California Superior Court, and President Trump name-checked Dalilah in this year’s State of the Union. The House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee passed Dalilah’s Law, H.R. 5688, last month; the Senate companion has gone nowhere since February. Robinson says it is backing the House bill, which tightens CDL issuance but does not mention brokerages at all.

At the Transportation Intermediaries Association meeting in Phoenix last week, brokers were already bracing for two outcomes rather than one. A loss at SCOTUS cracks open F4A preemption and exposes 3PLs to a patchwork of state liability claims. Even a Robinson win could push Congress to amend F4A so that “with respect to motor vehicles” explicitly reaches brokerages. The CBS report, airing while the justices are still writing, makes the second path materially more likely.

So What? Brokers are in the public spotlight now, and the Supreme Court decision due by June is no longer the only lever that matters. Tighten your carrier vetting paper trail this week, document every FMCSA data check, and assume a future compliance regime that won’t let you point at federal licensure as the full answer. A Robinson win in Montgomery may still trigger an F4A rewrite on the Hill, and that rewrite will be written to the CBS footage, not the oral argument transcript.

Read the full story →

Top Stories

Alan Ritchey shutters Phillipsburg hub, cuts 176 jobs

Valley View, Texas-based Alan Ritchey Inc. is closing its 511,200-square-foot Phillipsburg Logistics Center in New Jersey and laying off 176 workers effective July 17, according to a WARN notice filed with state labor officials. The closure stems from the non-renewal of a U.S. Postal Service contract. Combined with the 729-employee reduction in Aurora, Colo., earlier this year when USPS insourced a regional transfer hub, the carrier has shed more than 900 positions in 2026 as the Postal Service pulls contracted logistics work back in-house.

So What? Any carrier or 3PL with heavy USPS contract exposure should run the math on concentration risk this week. USPS is accelerating in-house consolidation, and back-to-back facility closures at Alan Ritchey signal that the restructuring still has runway.

Read the full story →

CBP launches $166B CAPE refund portal for IEEPA tariffs

U.S. Customs and Border Protection activated Phase 1 of the Consolidated Administration and Processing of Entries tool inside the ACE Secure Data Portal on Monday, opening the door for importers to reclaim roughly $127 billion in the first wave of refunds. The February Supreme Court ruling invalidated “Liberation Day” duties imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, clearing a path for $166 billion in total repayments across 56,000 registered importers. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has warned that tariffs could return under different authorities as early as July.

So What? File early. Phase 1 covers unliquidated entries and entries within 80 days of liquidation, and CBP says valid refunds land in 60 to 90 days. Complex claims, including a $2.9 billion subset, move to manual processing and will take longer.

Read the full story →

FMC Chair DiBella: U.S. has lost its maritime focus

Federal Maritime Commission Chair Laura DiBella, less than six months into her term, said the agency’s agenda has been pulled abroad by the Strait of Hormuz, the Panama Canal, Chinese ship detentions and flags of convenience. The commission rejected Maersk’s emergency fuel surcharge request for a third time after the carrier failed to document how higher bunker prices were hitting its business. DiBella pointed to the SHIPS Act and the administration’s Maritime Action Plan as the vehicles for rebuilding U.S. shipping, and held up India’s rapid industry expansion as proof the turnaround can happen in years rather than decades.

So What? The third Maersk denial sets a documentation bar for every carrier weighing an emergency surcharge filing. DiBella also said special-permission decisions now move to full commissioner vote, which means surcharge timelines lengthen and the paperwork burden rises.

Read the full story →

Sponsored By Trimble

Beyond Tracking: How Real-Time Visibility Fuels Fleet Profitability Real-time visibility is no longer a track-and-trace checkbox. Trimble’s latest paper lays out how integrated telematics and visibility data feed dispatch, billing and customer service decisions that move the margin line. See where the highest-ROI use cases sit in your current operation. Read the full story →

California quietly ramps up diesel TRU enforcement

With the Advanced Clean Fleets and Advanced Clean Truck rules on the sidelines, the California Air Resources Board has started pushing enforcement of its 2022 transport refrigeration unit regulations without a formal announcement. The Benesch law firm flagged the shift after client notices started arriving in recent weeks. Warehouses, distribution centers, grocery stores, seaports and intermodal railyards that receive refrigerated cargo now face quarterly reporting or compliance declaration requirements, and TRU owners based outside California must still register units through CARB’s ARBER system. Fines run as high as $10,000 per day.

So What? If a diesel TRU crosses into California, confirm it is registered, labeled and using compliant refrigerants before the next inbound load. Warehouses are now on the hook for reporting the carriers that show up at their docks, which means enforcement pressure lands on shippers and receivers as much as it lands on fleets.

Read the full story →

Sponsored By PrePass

The Mounting Risks of Missed Bypasses Every missed weigh station bypass is lost time, fuel and productivity. As enforcement activity rises and margins stay thin, the cost of inconsistent bypass performance compounds across the network. PrePass breaks down what the data is telling carriers now. Read the full story →

From the Research Desk

What We’re Watching

▸ The Supreme Court will hand down Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II sometime between now and the end of June. The CBS report changes the political backdrop around the decision, and an F4A amendment on Capitol Hill is now a live scenario regardless of which way the justices rule.

▸ CBP projects valid refunds move in 60 to 90 days. Watch the first payout cohort in late June: the speed and accuracy of Phase 1 determine how importers plan for the $2.9 billion in complex claims still sitting in manual processing.

▸ CARB has not issued a public TRU enforcement announcement, yet warehouse notices are already going out. If a Commerce Clause challenge lands in court, as E&E Strategies’ Glen Kedzie suggested it might, the question of whether California can reach beyond its border into an Ohio carrier’s recordkeeping becomes the next big test.

That’s your Daily for today. See you tomorrow.

Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe here  |  Have a tip? Just reply to this email.

FreightWaves 405 Cherry St., Chattanooga TN 37402

Unsubscribe  |  Forward to a Friend  |  FreightWaves.com